Puddle Jumpers: Understanding the Debate and Their Role in Water Safety
Jan 23, 2026
Article by Nicole Fairfield with photo credit to Mikkela Fairfield
As a parent, it’s natural to want your child to feel confident and safe in the water. So, when the warm weather hits and pool season is upon us, many of us reach for the nearest flotation device, like a Puddle Jumper, to ensure our little ones stay afloat. But there’s a noticeable debate among aquatic professionals about whether these devices are really helping—or potentially making things worse.
A well-known example of this discussion comes from the Texas Swim Academy, which argues that Puddle Jumpers and similar Personal Flotation Devices (PFDs) put children at a higher risk. While there’s truth in their perspective—Puddle Jumpers do keep a child in a vertical position, which is closer to the ‘drowning position’—there are a few nuances worth addressing to clear up some misconceptions.
The Importance of Perspective
First, let's clarify: when aquatic professionals discuss the ‘drowning position,’ they're referring to a vertical stance in the water. This is the position where a child’s face and mouth may dip below the water surface, making it harder for them to breathe. It’s true that Puddle Jumpers keep kids in a diagonal or vertical position, which isn’t the ideal swimming posture. However, let's not confuse this with a position that directly leads to drowning.
Children can be in a vertical position and still stay safe. Think about water polo players who are treading water in a vertical stance, keeping their heads above the surface, and actively engaging their muscles. While it might feel challenging at times, they are not drowning—they’re simply using their body in a different way. The same is true for a child in a Puddle Jumper. While it’s not the most efficient way to swim, it's also not a 'drowning' position in and of itself.
The Risks of False Confidence
That being said, the real concern with Puddle Jumpers and similar devices lies in the false sense of security they can provide. Parents may mistakenly believe that their child is fully safe and capable in the water simply because they’re wearing a flotation device. This can lead to neglecting vital swimming lessons, a lack of awareness around water safety, and increased risk of drowning.
Puddle Jumpers are helpful in keeping a child afloat, but they don’t teach children how to properly swim or understand their buoyancy. Children can easily become reliant on the device without developing the critical skills they need to be independent and confident in the water.
The Benefits of Puddle Jumpers
Despite these risks, Puddle Jumpers do offer some benefits—especially for parents managing multiple young children. When you’re in the pool with more than one child under 5, it’s almost impossible to keep a constant hand on every little one. In those situations, Puddle Jumpers can provide an extra layer of safety, allowing parents a moment to focus on one child at a time. In fact, many parents find they’re able to juggle pool time with ease, rotating their attention between kids in the water.
Moreover, while a Puddle Jumper doesn’t promote the best swimming posture, it does help children gain water confidence. It allows them to feel the water without fear, and they can begin to explore their buoyancy and basic movements in the water. For young swimmers who are just beginning, this can be a valuable step toward acclimation.
Finding Balance: A Better Approach
The key, however, is not to over-rely on these devices. Here’s what I suggest:
- Limit Puddle Jumper Use: If you use a Puddle Jumper, aim to only let your child wear it for a portion of the swim time. If you’re in the pool with multiple children, rotate them in and out of the flotation device so that each child has equal opportunities to practice in the water without assistance. This will give them a chance to gain confidence while still practicing critical swimming skills.
- Encourage Water Exploration: While your child is in the Puddle Jumper, take the opportunity to let them experience the water in other ways. Show them how to blow bubbles, put their face in the water, and kick their legs. These small practices help to build muscle memory and comfort in the water, which will be beneficial when it's time to transition to independent swimming.
- Understand the Limitations: Remember that Puddle Jumpers keep children in an upright position, which isn’t ideal for developing proper swimming posture. Swim lessons will still be necessary to teach children how to hold their body in a horizontal position, float, and move efficiently through the water.
- Work with Your Swim Instructor: When your child starts lessons, understand that the transition from a vertical position (with a Puddle Jumper) to a horizontal one will take time. Swim instructors will need to break the muscle memory associated with the flotation device and teach proper swimming techniques. But with time, your child will adapt, and the skills will stick.
- Safety First: It’s essential to remember that Puddle Jumpers are not substitutes for supervision. No flotation device can replace vigilant, active supervision by a parent or guardian. Always stay within arm’s reach of your child, and be prepared to step in immediately if necessary.
Final Thoughts
While aquatic professionals have valid concerns about the potential dangers of Puddle Jumpers and similar devices, it’s important not to vilify parents who choose to use them. Instead of bashing the use of Puddle Jumpers, we should be focusing on how to use them effectively and safely, ensuring they’re just one part of the equation in building water safety knowledge and swimming skills.
Parents, use the Puddle Jumper as a tool, not a crutch. Balance it with lessons, practice, and mindful water exploration, and you’ll help your child gain both confidence and competence in the water. At the end of the day, it’s about fostering an environment where your child can learn, grow, and—most importantly—stay safe in and around water.
Let’s work together to encourage responsible water use and training, and keep the conversation positive and focused on making our kids safer swimmers.
Stay connected with news and updates!
Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.
Don't worry, your information will not be shared.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.
